Applications and Demonstrations


In order to understand the application of Enneagrams in the real world, it is important to recognize the ways they have been used in different situations. This blog post is about how medical students can apply their numbers and how they can work on showing empathy towards their patients. 

In thinking in terms regarding a physician/patient relationship, empathy may be shown when the physician is in the process of trying to understand how a patient is reacting to or experiencing their medical condition or even their treatment. When you give a patient a diagnosis and medical aid, how do you expect that certain person to react? If a patient has an experience outside of the norms predicted by other patients with similar medical conditions, how is the physician supposed to understand if the patient reacts differently? 

In general, a person may appear to be more or less empathetic, and the understanding for one's accommodation for empathy can be approximated by a diagram which represents nine personality types, The Enneagram. The Enneagram is a personality theory describing nine patterns, or paradigms, one follows subconsciously throughout one's life. When you apply this way of understanding personality types in relation to medical students, predictions about one's medical condition and their reaction may call for patient empathy.

 There was a study held to understand medical students and their ways of empathy determining their personality types. Not only did this study evaluate how Enneagrams are implemented in their job and their role with empathy, the researchers also took into consideration how they could improve their ways of empathy with their patients. My job today is to dive deeper into this experiment and to disclose how much of an impact the Enneagram has made to help complete their study.

Before we continue, shall we review the numbers? Number one is the perfectionist, and in simple terms, they need everything to be perfect. Number two is the helper, they help without even knowing it. Number three is the achiever which usually seeks validation regarding their performance in a certain circumstance. Number four is the individualist and they love to feel their emotions. Number five is titled the investigator due to their liking to research every question they ask. Number six tends to be the most anxious number, which is the loyalist. Number seven is the enthusiast and they are very optimistic. Number eight seems to be the most headstrong number which is the challenger. Finally, number nine is the peacemaker which likes to stay in the middle of certain argument's to keep the peace. 

Let's jump in!

The purpose of this experiment was to "evaluate differences in empathy among medical students using the Enneagram typology" (Korean J Med Educ.). To start this study, questionnaires were given to preclinical students because, "...their empathy is expected in a good state of preservation and not biased by clinical clerkship experiences" (Section 1). The questionnaire contained an empathy scale, an Enneagram personality test, and details of the participants. 

A major important factor that researchers used to conduct this study was the implementation of Triads. According to the article, "Triads refers to the basic three components of the human psyche: instincts, feelings, and thinking" (Section 3). The Triad is in relation to body intelligence. The table given in the article explains how different numbers fall back to either instincts, feelings, or thinking. Numbers 8, 9, and 1 (the challenger, the peacemaker, and the perfectionist) reflect the instinctive sub-group. Type 8's act out their rage and expose it through their body language. Type 9's deny rage and do not sense body signals. Type 1's expose rage through a tense body. The feeling types are 2, 3, and 4 (the helper, the achiever, and the individualist). 2's pay attention to other's feelings while ignoring their own. Type 3 suppresses feelings from the heart. Type 4's express their feelings in a deeper manner. The last Triad sub-group is thinking and those types are 5, 6, and 7 (the investigator, the loyalist, and the enthusiast). Type 5 focuses on mastering knowledge. 6's seek support of authority or protective figures. Type 7's tend to focus on future plans. 

The results from testing the recipients, the Triad strategy described how the feeling triad was the same at dealing with empathy as the instinctive triad was. With the different categories the questionnaire held, the feeling and thinking triads were the best at perspective talking. The feeling triad was the most compassionate with care and the instinctive triad was highest with putting themselves in their patients shoes.

In regards to the recipients Enneagram numbers, 2's were the best at standing in the patient's shoes, 7 was the best at perspective talking, and 2's were highest at compassionate care. 

How do these results help the students improve their models of empathy? They will recognize what categories they are not strong at and they will take that into consideration and work to the best of their ability to improve their relationship with the patient. 

This study was very proficient in explaining what their intentions were with the questionnaire and how they would be using the results to assist the medical students. As the students improve their empathy and apply it into the real world, I advise that us as humans shall do the same.


Resources:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6589630/#:~:text=Enneagram%20type%20can%20be%20used,can%20be%20maintained%20and%20improved.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enneagram_of_Personality#Research_and_criticism

Comments

  1. This is a really fantastic summary and commentary on this great academic article. I really like the ways that you are suggesting we can USE these personality types to inform the way we interact with one another.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts